OTTAWA - The Federal Court of Appeal has dismissed a bid by the Prince Edward Island Potato Board to overturn a 2021 decision by the federal agriculture minister to declare the entire province as “a place infested with potato wart.â€
That order prohibited the export of seed potatoes from the Island to prevent the spread of the soil-borne fungus, which deforms potatoes and makes them impossible to sell.
The board had argued in Federal Court that the decision was unreasonable because there was insufficient evidence to establish that P.E.I. was infested with the fungus.
In April 2023, the Federal Court dismissed the board's application for a judicial review, saying the order was reasonable because the ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø Food Inspection Agency said regulatory measures had failed to prevent the transmission of potato wart to unregulated fields.
On Tuesday, the Appeal Court dismissed the board's appeal, saying the lower court had selected the correct reasonableness standard to review the minister's order.
As well, it found the lower court was correct in accepting the minister's view that the province was "infested" because the department had detected potato wart on 35 occasions in P.E.I.'s three counties since 2000.
This report by ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø was first published Nov. 5, 2024.
